RAID 5 Doomed? The Myth Debunked
As recently as October of 2008, a story on the newswires
predicting the failure (pardon the pun) of RAID 5 as an effective data
storage system has caused some disturbance in the IT community, if only
because of its somewhat opinionated nature. The story, which ran on ZDNet
as well as some of the other main IT industry rags, noted that SATA hard
drive capacity, now reaching above the 2 terabyte level, could be a drag
on future RAID 5 growth, and, and here's where the controversy comes in,
actually INCREASE the potential for read errors during disk construction.
In the article, the ZdNet columnist notes that SATA drives can suffer
from unrecoverable read rates of 10^14, which extrapolates that these
disk drives are unable to read a sector once every 100 trillion bits read.
As many familiar with the data storage industry have noted, drives are
already well above the two terabyte capacity level, which with this logic
in mind, makes it all but inevitable when attempting disk reconstruction
from a seven drive RAID 5 system failure.
Where things begin to get shifty is where the article claims that during
recovery, the array volume is likely to declare itself unreadable, thus
stopping the RAID recovery or self-repair. From this point, the article
also notes that once this event occurs during the recovery process, it
is more than likely all 12 terabytes stored on this hypothetical RAID
system will be lost. Or in the least, require professional RAID data recovery
A Dead RAID On Every Corner?
While certainly what the ZDNet article boasts would seem to be a huge
boon for the RAID recovery industry ("Imagine a world with dead RAIDs
on every corner!"), we believe this to be far from the case. The writer
then goes on to throw in several basic premises about hdd technologies,
such as the fact that mechanical parts tend to fail, tight data density
can also increase failure rates, and that RAID 6 could be an expensive,
but effective solution to this perceived issue.
Click here to get a RAID recovery
The real problem with the article is actually quite simple. What the article
does note is the "soft error rate," which is the rate at which data could
possibly be misread incorrectly a single time, but NOT multiple times.
Therefore, in everyday RAID storage system use, this number is really
useless. Because of ECC encoding (Error Correcting Code) in most hard
disk drives, the likelihood of failing to record more than a few bits
and being unable to correct from it is almost impossible. Using the soft
error rate is therefore a poor rate with which to base a story on.
What the story should have been based upon is sector size and amount of
ECC per hard disk sector. Additionally, the idea that a RAID will fail
simply because of the size of its component hard drives is quite a fallacy
as well. While technically the more drives connected increase the chances
of a single drive failure, it is the number of drives connected to the
system that ensure that this single drive CAN be recovered WITHOUT damaging
the full array.
A prime example of this might be a RAID 10 system (Hard Drive Recovery
Group has recovered hundreds of RAID systems, including RAID 50 or "RAID
of RAIDs"). In order for a RAID 10 to fail and have its data unrecoverable,
two of the drives in the array must have the EXACT data mirrored and failed
during a very, very short time period during which the initial failed
drive is not repaired before the second drive fails. As you can tell,
there are a lot of ifs ands or buts in this scenario. Not only is it unlikely,
but highly improbable. The result? RAID 5 will live on. The low price
of hard disk drives ensures this is all but a certainty.
Professional Help Is Here
Remember that at Hard Drive Recovery Group, a consultation
is always free. Don’t take chances when it comes to your mission
critical RAID-stored data. Call us first.
Click here to request a free RAID
data recovery quote.
All material on this website is copyright 1995-2017
Hard Drive Recovery Group.
All Rights Reserved.
24 Hour RAID Repair
5 Data Recovery
RAID 10 Data Recovery
SAN Tape Recovery
Server Data Recovery
SCSI Data Recovery
RAID Tape Recovery
RAID 5: Doomed?
RAID File Restoration
Exchange 5.5 Data Recovery
PowerEdge Data Recovery
Repair Your RAID
Mac RAID Recovery
Linux RAID Recovery
RAID Drive Failure
Drive Not Ready
Fixed Disk Parameter Table Bios
Disk Read Error
IBM ServeRAID Error 2807
Hard Drive Not Recognized